Reel Simple

Welcome to Reel Simple, a beautifully maintained Finger Lakes vacation rental located on the peaceful southern shore of Conesus Lake. This charming three-bedroom, two-bath vacation home perfectly balances rustic cottage warmth with modern comfort, offering guests a serene lakefront escape ideal for families, couples, or friends. Whether you’re seeking quiet relaxation or adventure on the water, Reel Simple provides the perfect home base for your Finger Lakes getaway.

From the moment you arrive, the tranquil setting and thoughtful design of this lake home set the tone for your stay. Nestled along a calm stretch of shoreline, Reel Simple offers an intimate connection to the lake with panoramic views that stretch the full length of Conesus. The property’s tasteful “Pottery Barn”-inspired décor combines neutral tones, natural textures, and timeless accents, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere throughout.

Step into the cozy living room, where a striking stone gas fireplace takes center stage. Its soft glow provides the perfect backdrop for relaxing evenings after a day on the water. Plush seating surrounds the hearth, encouraging you to curl up with a good book or enjoy a movie on the flat-screen television.

With double-planked hardwood floors running throughout, the space feels both grounded and sophisticated, capturing the essence of modern cottage living. The open-concept layout creates effortless flow between the living room and kitchen, making it easy to spend time together while cooking, dining, or unwinding.

The full kitchen at this vacation home blends rustic charm with practical elegance. Updated countertops and a stainless-steel sink complement the modern appliances, including a full-size refrigerator and freezer, oven, and microwave. Whether you’re preparing a hearty breakfast before a day of kayaking or an evening meal featuring local ingredients, this kitchen has everything you need.

Adjacent to the kitchen, the bright dining room and adjoining sunroom provide the perfect places to gather. Large windows frame breathtaking lake views, filling the space with natural light. It’s easy to imagine mornings spent sipping coffee as the sun rises over the water or lingering over dinner while the sky glows with the colors of sunset.

A full bathroom with a shower and an in-home washer and dryer complete the main level, providing convenience for longer stays.

Upstairs, this Finger Lakes vacation rental offers three inviting bedrooms designed for comfort and relaxation. The master suite features a cozy double bed and a private bathroom with a shower, offering a peaceful retreat for unwinding at the end of the day. Two additional bedrooms, one with two twin beds and the other with a full over full bunk bed, making them ideal for children, friends, or extended family.

Soft linens, simple décor, and lake-inspired color palettes ensure every room feels calm and restorative.

Step outside to discover this lake home’s spacious patio surrounded by raised flower beds and beautiful landscaping. This outdoor space is perfect for dining al fresco, enjoying a glass of wine at sunset, or simply taking in the panoramic views of Conesus Lake. From this southern vantage point, you can see nearly the entire length of the lake—a view that never fails to impress.

The gently sloping lawn leads to the private lakefront, where the home’s natural shoreline offers an authentic Finger Lakes experience. Due to the property’s location and natural setting, access to the water is through shoreline vegetation, so guests should use care when entering and exiting the lake. Spend sunny afternoons relaxing by the water as ducks glide past.

It’s a peaceful place to slow down, soak up the scenery, and enjoy the laid-back rhythm of lake life.

Conesus Lake is known for its pristine waters and welcoming community atmosphere. The surrounding area offers a wealth of activities and attractions to suit every interest. Golfers will find several excellent courses nearby, while those seeking a slower pace can browse the local markets and antique shops that dot the region.

During the summer, the lake buzzes with gentle activity—kayaks, fishing boats, and laughter echoing from the shoreline. Autumn transforms the landscape into a patchwork of color, ideal for leaf-peeping and photography. Winter visitors can enjoy ice fishing and cozy evenings by the fireplace, making Reel Simple a four-season destination for every kind of traveler.

Within an hour’s drive, you’ll find the Canandaigua Lake Wine Trail and the Keuka Lake Wine Trail, featuring award-winning wineries and tasting rooms. Explore the Finger Lakes wine country, picking up local produce to prepare delicious meals at your vacation home. Outdoor activities abound, including horseback riding near Seneca Lake, fishing in Canandaigua Lake or Keuka Lake, hiking through picturesque state parks, a day trip to nearby Rochester, or visiting regional waterfalls.

There's something for everyone in the Finger Lakes region!

Reel Simple captures everything that makes a Finger Lakes vacation rental so special—tranquil water views, timeless comfort, and the perfect balance of adventure and relaxation. Whether you’re paddling across the calm morning water, sharing stories around the firepit, or simply enjoying a quiet evening with loved ones, every moment spent here feels restorative. This charming vacation home embodies the best of Conesus Lake—simple pleasures, natural beauty, and space to reconnect.

Once you’ve experienced the serenity of Reel Simple, you’ll understand why guests return year after year to this lakeside haven. Book your stay at Reel Simple today and experience a lakefront getaway where comfort meets classic Finger Lakes charm.

Per New York state and county regulations, the occupancy for this property is strictly limited. The maximum occupancy stated on this listing is the number of guests allowed on the premises at any given time, including infants and children. This includes both day and overnight guests, no exceptions.

Note: 1. Smoking is not allowed in any rental property. This includes vaping and e-cigarettes.

2. Homes are not handicap accessible, unless stated in the description. 3.

Air conditioning is not available unless listed as an amenity. If available, air conditioning is considered a seasonal amenity and is only available May 15 - October 15. 4.

Where pets are allowed it is indicated. Otherwise, pets are not allowed. Homes are not guaranteed allergen-free, even those that do not allow pets.

5. Docking capabilities may vary based on current water levels. Docking is not guaranteed if water levels are low and/or high due to seasonal weather and climate changes.

6. Outdoor amenities, including furniture, watercraft and firepit are not available between October 15 - May 15.